Cryptocurrency widget, price, heatmap
Arrow
Burger icon
Cryptocurrency widget, price, heatmap
News/CFTC Nominees Face Senate Scrutiny as Kalshi Halts Trump Mention Contracts

CFTC Nominees Face Senate Scrutiny as Kalshi Halts Trump Mention Contracts

Van Thanh Le

Van Thanh Le

•

PublishedNov 18, 2026

•

UpdatedNov 18, 2026

15 hours ago4 minutes read
CFTC nominees face Senate scrutiny over prediction market public benefits

Federal-State Regulatory Dispute Intensifies as Lawmakers Question Prediction Markets' Public Benefits

TL;DR

  • President Donald Trump's CFTC nominees, Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick, faced Senate scrutiny over prediction markets, with Rowland questioning their public benefits and both confronting disputes over state and federal authority.
  • The CFTC ordered Kalshi to halt certain contracts predicting President Trump's remarks and opened proceedings to determine whether the platform falsely certified those markets.
  • State and tribal gambling authorities continue challenging federal oversight, while lawmakers raised concerns about regulatory staffing, political influence and the future of prediction market rules.

Trade smarter on Jupiter, Solana’s leading DEX built for fast execution and deep liquidity. 

Swap tokens at competitive rates, route across multiple liquidity sources automatically, and access perpetuals, DCA, and advanced trading tools — all in one place!


President Donald Trump's nominees to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) faced questions from U.S. senators on November 17, 2026, over the agency's authority to regulate prediction markets, as a growing legal dispute pits federal derivatives oversight against state and tribal gambling laws. Democratic nominee Matthew Rowland questioned the public benefits of certain event contracts, while Republican nominee Nathan Anonick acknowledged the legal complexity surrounding the industry. Separately, the CFTC ordered prediction market operator Kalshi to halt certain contracts tied to Trump's public remarks and began reviewing whether the company complied with earlier regulatory guidance.

The Senate Agriculture Committee hearing focused on how the nominees would approach prediction market regulation if confirmed. Both previously worked for the committee on opposing sides of the political aisle and were questioned for more than an hour, with mostly Democratic lawmakers attending. Their nominations come as the CFTC seeks to defend its regulatory authority over event contracts offered by platforms including Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase, while facing legal challenges from states that consider some of those products unauthorized gambling.

Rowland Questions Prediction Markets' Public Benefits as States Challenge CFTC Authority

Rowland said federal law requires the CFTC to consider the public interest when evaluating certain event contracts. He urged the agency to "think long and hard about balancing the public interest against the kind of economic usefulness of these contracts." The nominee also pointed to Regulation 40.11, adopted in 2011, which prohibits registered exchanges from listing or accepting for clearing certain event contracts involving gaming, terrorism, war and assassination. Rowland said he hoped to help develop the CFTC's proposed regulations for prediction markets if confirmed.

Rowland acknowledged the ongoing legal challenges and expressed support for working with state and tribal authorities. "It's hard for me to comment on the active litigation that the CFTC is engaged in, but I'm certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised and would want to work with them further if I were confirmed on that," he said.

Under Chairman Michael Selig, the CFTC has asserted that it has "exclusive jurisdiction" over event contracts. The agency's proposed regulatory approach treats prediction market contracts as swaps tied to future events, placing them under federal commodities oversight rather than state gambling laws. States have challenged that position, arguing that prediction market operators offer illegal gambling products while avoiding state regulations and tax obligations. Tribal organizations have also warned that such platforms could circumvent existing tribal-state gaming agreements.

Nearly a dozen states and the CFTC have become involved in litigation over prediction market oversight, with federal courts reaching opposing conclusions. Some courts have treated the platforms' business model as comparable to casinos subject to state regulation, while another federal court has sided with the industry's federal oversight argument. The conflicting decisions have raised the possibility that the U.S. Supreme Court could ultimately address the jurisdictional dispute.

Sen. Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat, challenged the federal government's position, saying, "I actually do think the law is quite clear that jurisdiction over sports gambling rests in the hands of states and also with tribes — and yet prediction markets continue to operate, I believe in violation of these state and tribal laws."

Anonick, who previously served on the Republican staff of the Senate Agriculture Committee, acknowledged the sensitivity of the dispute and said he would respect any eventual Supreme Court ruling. "It's a very charged, emotional issue, and I appreciate how sensitive it is," he said. Anonick also noted that the CFTC has discretion to assess whether certain event contracts conflict with the public interest and said he intended to listen to stakeholders.

Smith rejected the characterization of the dispute as emotional, responding, "I don't think that this is an emotional issue. I think this is a legal issue. I think it is a core legal tenet that is laid out in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, as well as the rights of states to regulate sports betting."

CFTC Staffing and Trump Family Connections Draw Additional Questions

The confirmation hearing also addressed the CFTC's staffing levels, commission vacancies and the potential influence of political connections on regulatory enforcement. Trump nominated Rowland and Anonick the previous week, and both are widely expected to receive confirmation before the current congressional session ends. If approved, they would join Selig, currently the commission's sole member, bringing the agency closer to the five-member structure established under federal law.

Lawmakers questioned the vacancies at the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission, both of which have faced scrutiny over incomplete commissions and bipartisan representation. A senator noted that the CFTC had lost about a quarter of its previous workforce amid Selig's leadership and the Trump administration's broader federal staffing reductions, even as its responsibilities expanded into cryptocurrency and prediction markets. Both nominees expressed openness to additional staffing if necessary, while Anonick said that "a full commission is the best approach to sound, durable policy."

Sen. Raphael Warnock, a Georgia Democrat, raised concerns about potential conflicts involving the president's family and prediction market businesses, including Donald Trump Jr.'s direct involvement in the industry. Warnock cited allegations in published accounts that "the CFTC's political leadership has stopped senior career officials from looking into firms that had business dealings with the Trump family." The senator then asked, "Should a company's ties with the president or his family ever affect how the CFTC treats it?"

Both nominees rejected the idea that political connections should influence regulatory decisions. Rowland responded:

"I think that the law needs to be enforced fairly without fear or favor, and so the answer is no." Anonick agreed, saying, "I'd agree that I think the law should apply equally and fairly to everyone. It should not matter who is involved."

The Senate Agriculture Committee must vote on both nominations before they can advance to the full Senate. The confirmation schedule remains tight ahead of the next Congress in January, when unfinished nominations would generally need to be resubmitted.

Kalshi Halts Trump Mention Contracts as CFTC Opens Certification Review

The regulatory debate coincided with a separate CFTC enforcement action involving Kalshi's presidential mention markets, which allow traders to speculate on words or subjects Trump might use in public remarks. The agency stayed the certification of certain contracts and began proceedings to examine whether Kalshi had improperly certified them despite earlier warnings about manipulation risks. Kalshi confirmed that it had complied with the restriction, stating, "We are complying with the order."

A CFTC spokesperson explained the action, saying:

"Consistent with the CFTC’s mention market advisory from September, the CFTC stayed the certification of certain mention markets listed by Kalshi, pending further proceedings by the CFTC about those contracts’ susceptibility to manipulation."

The earlier advisory warned exchanges about potential manipulation involving contracts whose outcomes depend on "the discrete conduct of a named person, and that conduct may be neither independently generated nor externally verifiable." The regulator said such markets could be considered "presumptively readily susceptible to manipulation," reminding registered exchanges that they may offer only "derivative contracts that are not readily susceptible to manipulation."

The CFTC's latest order initiated proceedings over whether Kalshi's certification met those requirements. "The commission has determined to institute proceedings for filing a false certification concerning the contracts," the agency wrote. It emphasized that the decision did not establish a definitive prohibition on presidential mention markets.

"This order reflects no final determination that a presidential mention contract can or cannot comply with the act. Rather, it directs Kalshi to — in light of intervening staff guidance — demonstrate the compliance it previously certified."

The proceedings will allow Kalshi to defend its earlier certification while the regulator evaluates the contracts' vulnerability to manipulation. The extent of the restriction beyond Kalshi's Trump-related markets remains unresolved, including whether other regulated exchanges received similar orders or whether the agency might extend the measure to additional government officials.

Mention markets have attracted regulatory scrutiny because individuals with advance knowledge of public remarks could potentially exploit that information when trading. An earlier enforcement case involved a former White House teleprompter operator accused of placing bets based on what the president was expected to say. Sen. Elizabeth Warren also recently demanded an explanation from a White House lawyer about measures intended to prevent a repeat of an insider-trading episode involving the administration.

Despite suspending Trump-related offerings, Kalshi continued listing a contract tied to remarks Vice President JD Vance might make at an event scheduled for the following day. The platform had also reduced its sports-related mention markets, while many remaining offerings focused on statements made during corporate earnings calls. The industry's argument for the economic usefulness of such contracts centers on the ability of political and corporate leaders to influence financial markets through their public statements.

This article has been refined and enhanced by ChatGPT.

Cryptocurrency widget, price, heatmap
v 5.16.5
© 2017 - 2026 COIN360.com. All Rights Reserved.